Skip to main content

Dublin MEP alleges Garda 'brutality'

Conor Lally - Irish Times

Dublin Socialist Party MEP Paul Murphy has lodged a formal complaint with the Garda Síochána Ombudsman Commission over alleged mistreatment by gardaí policing a protest in Co Mayo.

Mr Murphy claims he was subjected to excessive force by gardaí during the protest over Shell’s Corrib gas project last Thursday.

Paul Murphy MEP hands in a letter with photographs allegedly showing garda brutality to the Garda Ombudsman on Abbey Street. Dublin.Photograph: Brenda Fitzsimons /Irish Times

Mr Murphy said he was left with bruising and was unable to chew properly for a number of days after gardaí used ‘pressure point’ techniques on him when removing him and other protesters.

He has submitted photographs of himself, taken by others, while being removed from a sit-down protest on a roadway. Some of the photos show small bruises, which Mr Murphy says he sustained when being subjected to the  techniques.

These tactics are used by the Garda and prison officers to subdue prisoners or people who pose a public order risk They involve using fingers to apply pressure to certain areas of the body, including behind the ear, aimed at physically subduing a person for a short period to allow their arrest or removal from a public order incident.

Mr Murphy’s complaint is that the force used against him and others was excessive to any risk posed by the protest on the day. He described the actions of some gardaí as “outrageous”.

“Garda brutality has been a persistent feature of the situation in Rossport since the end of 2006, when the area was effectively militarised with hundreds of gardaí coming in to the area,” he said. “At that time, protestors including myself, were subject to serious assaults by the gardaí, including being thrown into ditches, beaten with batons and deliberately punched.”

He said during the incident last Thursday he was one of a group that sat on a roadway to block Shell vehicles from carrying out works laying a pipeline that will carry sludge with gas, from the sea to Shell’s on-shore plant for refining into gas.

Mr Murphy claims gardaí were aggressive when they moved in and made no attempt to use any approach apart from an extreme one. He says he was picked up by four or five gardaí, had the area behind his ear and his left jaw pressed hard and also suffered blows to his ribs and head.

He was among a group removed from the road and put behind Garda lines, though they were not arrested.

Mr Murphy lodged his complaint this afternoon at the offices in Dublin of the Garda Ombudsman.

He said he had no confidence his complaint would progress in any meaningful fashion, pointing out that of the 111 complaints lodged in relation to the policing of the Shell to Sea protests, 78 were deemed inadmissible by the Ombudsman and seven were sent to the DPP.

“Most strikingly, only one file was sent to Garda Commissioner’s office calling for disciplinary procedures. To date, no disciplinary action has been taken.”


Posted Date: 
1 September 2011